THE BRIEF
CLAIRE CAO FANG · FOUNDER, WHOLLY MOLY!2017 · COMMERCIAL LAUNCH2019 · RMB100M REPORTED SALES2020 · LIGHTWEIGHT PACKAGING

PEOPLE / CONSUMER BRANDS

A FOUNDER’S WORK · 01

Claire Cao Fang and the art of making oats belong

Before Wholly Moly! reached Chinese breakfast tables, Claire Cao Fang had worked on sports brands and internet businesses. Her next venture began with an old friend, an overlooked ingredient and a rather practical question: how would people actually use it?

Oat bran presents a small problem for a brand marketer. It has no obvious glamour, no dramatic silhouette and little chance of being mistaken for a luxury good. Claire Cao Fang chose to build a company around it anyway. At Wholly Moly!, an ingredient became a series of ordinary things people could use: a porridge, a drink, something to keep in the cupboard. The interesting part of her story lies in the distance between having a product and having a place in someone’s day.

Fang had worked with brands that already possessed a place in people’s imaginations. Her career included sports marketing and internet ventures, followed by a Wharton MBA. Oats presented a different assignment. An unfamiliar proposition had to become sufficiently familiar to buy, prepare and buy again. Breakfast, after all, is an appointment people tend to keep without consulting a brand strategist.

An old friend, a new assignment

Before the company had products on shelves, it had a friendship. Fang and her cofounder, Xue Huijing, had known each other since middle school. Their eventual business partnership brought together two people whose knowledge of one another preceded any pitch deck. That is a quieter beginning than the usual entrepreneurial encounter, and a more personal one.

They also brought different professional histories. Xue had worked in management at a technology company. Fang came from global brand marketing. Their collaboration began taking shape in 2014; the brand would enter the Chinese market in 2017. Between those dates sat the less photogenic business of figuring out what to make and whom to make it for.

Fang’s earlier employers included Adidas, Nike and BBDO. Her company biography describes work at Adidas’s global headquarters, Nike’s China brand-marketing operation and BBDO’s China business, serving PepsiCo food brands. It also records entrepreneur-in-residence and managing director experience with Rocket Internet. These were different environments, with different relationships between a product, a customer and the machinery that connects them.

She studied at Fudan University’s School of Journalism and attended Wharton from 2012 to 2014, earning an MBA with concentrations in entrepreneurship and finance. Her biography includes a second, less desk-bound education: travel across all seven continents, a trek to Everest Base Camp at twenty, snowboarding and diving. The outdoor particulars give the executive résumé some air. There is more to a life than a sequence of employers.

The career change carried its own useful tension. Established sports brands arrive with associations already attached. A young grain-food business has to build its associations while also making the food, arranging production and finding customers. Fang’s next job would require the public-facing judgment of a marketer and the patience to deal with everything behind the package.

Before the launch, the listening

The early team spent time asking questions. During the first half of 2015, it conducted three rounds of consumer research over six months. There were several hundred questionnaires; at least half involved individual interviews. The exercise examined the grain-food category and what younger consumers in major Chinese cities wanted from it.

That detail deserves to linger. A questionnaire can produce an attractive chart. A conversation can complicate it. People have opinions about taste, preparation and the experience of opening a box that refuse to fit into a neat slogan. Doing both meant the team was gathering more than a broad expression of interest. It was asking what an actual product might have to deliver.

The first generation arrived in 2017 with thick-cut oats and a five-grain product. The range subsequently spread across several formats. The business retained a connection to grains while giving the customer more than one way to encounter them. A cupboard can accommodate variety rather more easily than an abstract brand proposition.

A hand holding a small Wholly Moly! bottle beside a window and plants
A breakfast idea, with a handle on everyday life. Wholly Moly!’s product photography brings the grain drink out of the packet. Photograph: Wholly Moly!.

Fang’s explanation of the oat-bran proposition began with a modest admission: “We didn’t invent oat bran”. The innovation she described concerned incorporating it into everyday life in China. That puts the creative work at the point of use. The founder was choosing a relationship between an existing ingredient and the person expected to prepare it.

Consider the instant porridge. A familiar form makes a new product easier to place. A person can understand the occasion, the vessel and the basic preparation before deciding whether the ingredient appeals. The company’s powdered drink offered another route into a warm cup. These are small decisions viewed individually, but they shape the amount of effort a customer must contribute.

By 2019, Wholly Moly! reported RMB100 million in annual sales. In 2020, it announced a nearly US$10 million Series A led by C Ventures. Those figures mark the company’s early commercial progress. They also introduce the next part of Fang’s story: a founder with capital to deploy and a clear view of the risks that spending could create.

The cheerful name and the serious arithmetic

Wholly Moly! is a name with an exclamation mark permanently built into it. Fang’s advice about running a company was considerably more restrained. She placed financial planning at the center of preparation for uncertainty. Cash flow, product margins and the effectiveness of marketing spending all belonged in the founder’s immediate field of view.

Her warning extended to the temptation to pursue expensive growth in order to satisfy financing expectations. A company could keep chasing market share while losing track of the returns that would make its spending sustainable. She compared growth pursued for venture investors with operations shaped to please Wall Street. The concern was the direction a business takes when its financing audience becomes too influential.

A cheerful name does not balance a ledger.

An observation on Fang’s emphasis on financial planning

The point has an unusual force in a consumer business. A product is physical. Before a customer buys it, someone may already have committed money to ingredients, manufacturing and packaging. Marketing adds another expense. The founder has to connect the attractive object in the photograph to the commitments required to put that object into circulation.

Fang’s published advice keeps those commitments in view. It is an operating position rather than an aesthetic one. A brand can sound lively and still make measured decisions about money. Indeed, the two can coexist quite comfortably. A spreadsheet has never objected to an exclamation mark; it merely declines to be paid with one.

A package light enough to test

One packaging decision shows how Fang connected an environmental aspiration with a practical constraint. The company used Ecolean pouches for an oat drink in 2020. The format weighed five grams. It had an air-filled handle and a broad printable surface, giving a small package a recognizable shape.

The suggestion came from a contract manufacturer. Fang said the team had noticed the packaging on other products, but the recommendation prompted a closer examination. That is a useful glimpse of how a decision actually arrives: through someone involved in production, who can point a founder toward an option worth investigating.

THE 2020 OAT-DRINK PACKAGE5g

Packaging weight. A small physical detail with implications for materials and transport.

Fang also highlighted a lower minimum order quantity than traditional options. For a new line, a smaller required order allows a different kind of experiment. The team can commit to fewer packages while finding out how customers respond. The attractive pouch and the operating calculation belong to the same choice.

She wanted brands to encourage more environmentally conscious consumption. Here that ambition met the questions a founder has to ask before placing an order. Will the format suit the product? Can people use it comfortably? What must the company commit before learning whether it works? Environmental intention acquired a specific object and a specific purchasing decision.

The distance between a farm and a habit

Behind the familiar formats lay an international operation. Wholly Moly! sourced and processed ingredients in North America, with more complex recipes manufactured in Southeast Asia. It sold through Chinese online channels as well as physical retail, and reached American customers through Weee!. The bowl at the end of that route was decidedly simpler than the route itself.

For Fang, geographic variety also meant avoiding reliance on a single factory. That is a practical way to think about the international character of the company. Crossing borders adds coordination, but having more than one operating location creates options. The founder’s responsibility includes the arrangements that a customer should never have to consider.

There is a personal echo in that geography. Fang’s career and travels had already taken her beyond one market. At Wholly Moly!, movement became part of the company’s daily work. Experience acquired elsewhere had to become useful locally, in the form of a product that made sense without asking the consumer to study its itinerary.

The product story continued beyond the initial launch. A company entry for a food-industry competition records a hazelnut and black sesame oat-bran product, launched in 2023 and introduced into additional physical stores in July 2024. The flavors give a later example of the same assignment: finding another appealing way to make a grain product belong.

Fang’s story returns, finally, to the customer’s ordinary day. An old friend becomes a business partner. A marketer becomes a founder. Research becomes a product, and a packaging recommendation becomes an order. All of that effort ends in a small choice someone makes at home. For a company called Wholly Moly!, the desired outcome is wonderfully uneventful: something people know what to do with, and reach for again.